Change your thinking, change your life!

Consequences Of A

Spring-And-Loop Theory:


Comparing Physics Theories

YouTube [20min] | MP3 [20min]

by Floyd Maxwell, BASc


Comparing Physics Theories



Standard General Quantum String Quantum Gauge Loop Quantum Spring-And-Loop
Model Relativity Mechanics Theory Field Theory Theory Gravity Theory
Has a Planck-scale basis? 1 FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS FAIL FAIL PASS PASS
1 Physics today has a Planck-scale. A "no smaller than this" size.

If a theory does not build up from this minimum size, it will break (or is already broken).

Breakable, or broken, theories score a "fail" here.
 

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has a Planck-scale model? 2 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
2 Some physics theories talk of Planck-scale things, but can't model them.

Incompleteness rarely earns a passing grade.
 

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has a simple model? 3 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
3 Physics is almost completely bereft of simple models.

It should go without saying that the Standard Model (SM) is anything but simple. I would compare it
to the streets of Tokyo, where house numbers are not sequential, for example.

General Relativity (GR) is such a complex theory that Albert Einstein needed help from several college
students, as well as David Hilbert, before he got all the math squared away. Hilbert in fact beat Einstein
to the punch in the equation area, but graciously conceded Relativity was Einstein's baby all along.

Quantum Mechanics (QM) is more seance than simple. Like my sock drawer. Seen my green socks?

String Theory (ST) proposes a simple basis: everything is a string. Unfortunately, it is the theory farthest
from simplicity. This seeming contradiction is resolved by picturing a pyramid of simple blocks, only the
pyramid has been assembled completely upside down.

Quantum Field Theory (QFT), Gauge Theory (GT) and Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) are all incomplete,
fledgling or co-dependent theories. Trying to build on the SM, GR and/or QM can't lead to a simple model.
 

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Based in 3+1 dimensions? 4 FAIL PASS FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL PASS PASS
4 Contemporary physicists resemble encyclopedia salespeople. "These extra dimensions will make your
children smarter than your neighbor's children. Sign here."

Like all well-rehearsed objection handlers, you rarely hear them use the words "crutch" and "extra dimensions"
in the same sentence.

[Patched physics theories] are like sausages,
it is better not to see them being made.

- with apologies, and thanks, to Otto von Bismarck

So, extra dimensions are a crutch. Or, in the case of ST, a crock.

Of the Existing mainstream Physics theories (tEmP), only GR and LQG escape the need for extra
D-as-in-Duct tape dimensions.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves Vacuum Catastrophe? 5 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL FAIL Unknown PASS
5 Said quickly, 100 orders of magnitude is just a short phrase.

Let's try saying it with zeroes and ones...

1
      vs
              10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

Ok, thank goodness for small fonts.

Word representations your thing?

One.
            vs
                    Ten thousand trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion

But wait, it could be just 60 orders of magnitude, as someone on Slashdot patiently "corrected" me.

Or it could be 120 orders of magnitude, as was admitted for decades.

In any case, Spring-And-Loop Theory can account for every dollar, while tEmP theories lose track of
duotrigintillions (a vigintillion vigintillion).  Before breakfast.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves the Horizon problem? 6 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL FAIL Unknown PASS
6 The Horizon problem arises from "different regions of the universe (that have not contacted each
other because of the great distances between them"
), nevertheless having the same temperature.

In essence, if you think there was a Big Bang, you have a Horizon problem.

This problem is quite severe, and not easily treated by new particles palliatives nor "dark" calmatives.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves the Coronal Heating problem? 7 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
7 "The Coronal Heating problem in solar physics relates to the question of why the temperature of the
Sun's corona is millions of kelvin higher than that of the surface. The high temperatures require energy
to be carried from the solar interior to the corona by non-thermal processes, because the second law of
thermodynamics prevents heat from flowing directly from [a colder to a hotter place].

Spring-And-Loop Theory answered this in COASALT 6: 222 Answers.

tEmP theories will never resolve this until they align with the principles of Spring-And-Loop Theory.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Explains Diffuse Interstellar Bands? 8 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL Pass (More)
8 "The great problem with DIBs, apparent from the earliest observations, was that their central wavelengths
did not correspond with any known spectral lines of any ion or molecule, and so the material which was
responsible for the absorption could not be identified. A large number of theories were advanced as the
number of known DIBs grew, and determining the nature of the absorbing material (the 'carrier') became
a crucial problem in astrophysics.

Despite using the past tense -- which implies that DIBs are now a solved problem -- they are not a solved
problem. Except to Spring-And-Loop Theory, that intends to publish has now published on this topic
in the future.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Explains Sonoluminescence? 9 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
9 Sonoluminescence is another total mystery to tEmP theories.

Spring-And-Loop Theory took care of this in COASALT 6: 222 Answers.
 


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Says a black hole is a singularity? 10 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
10 When tEmP theories use the word 'singularity', they usually mean a point that is infinitely small.

The unabashed use of singularity is revealing of how shameless physics has become.

First called out in COASALT 2: Black Holes, singularities are the caution tape that delineates where things
are completely broken.

Old things. No longer useful things. tEmP theory things.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves information loss in black hole? 11 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
11 "The black hole information paradox results from the combination of quantum mechanics and general
relativity. It suggests that physical information could permanently disappear in a black hole, allowing many
physical states to devolve into the same state. This is controversial because it violates a commonly assumed
tenet of science -- that in principle complete information about a physical system at one point in time should
determine its state at any other time."

I double-checked, but didn't find the word 'attempting', as in "attempting to combine quantum mechanics
and general relativity".

It is long understood that QM and GR don't get along with each other, in the most fundamental of ways.

So why do tEmP theories continually try to crazy glue them together, without changing either theory?

And worse, why do they then tout the union despite the Hoover Dam sized pile of unresolved obstacles?

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
     Predicts maximum black hole gravity?12 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
12 The idea that a black hole could have a maximum gravity size was first suggested in COASALT 10:
Black Holes Revisited
.

tEmP theories don't have a chance on this one. Instead, they will continue their petrification process,
the logical result of dogmatic repetition of impossible nonsense.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
     Resolves galaxy rotation problem? 13 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
13 Explained by Spring-And-Loop Theory in COASALT 5: Gravity and COASALT 10: Black Holes Revisited,
the galaxy rotation problem (GRP) was first noticed in 1932.

The GRP is completely unresolved today by tEmP theories. Physics journals, however, couldn't be happier
as the GRP has spawned the 'dark matter' particle, island and subcontinent.

Count on mainstream media delivering a steady stream of dark rubbish for decades to come.
 


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves the Hierarchy Problem? 14 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
14 The Hierarchy Problem is "the large discrepancy between aspects of the weak force and gravity.
There is no scientific consensus on, for example, why the weak force is 1032 times stronger than gravity."

In other words, model inadequacy or breakage by tEmP theories.

Spring-And-Loop Theory is on record that "the weak force" is actually gravity working at the nuclear level.

Calculation:
If you compare nucleon-nucleon distance (at about 10-16 meters)
to the 1 meter distance from a person's arm to the Earth's surface,
you observe a difference of a factor of 1016.

As the gravitational attraction is related to the distance squared,
you then need to square this 1016 difference.

When you do that, the answer you get is 1032.


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has simple model of how gravity works?15 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
15 How could tEmP theories have a simple model of gravity when they don't understand gravity?
  • GR and Newtonian physics do not provide a low level understanding of gravity
  • Einstein spent the last thirty years of his life trying to understand gravity but got nowhere
  • Feynman spent a similar amount of time and produced similar results
And so we end up with the dark matter and dark energy juggernauts.

COASALT 5: Gravity explained the Spring-And-Loop Theory model of gravity.
That works at the smallest and largest scales.
 

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Explains what the speed of light is? 16 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
16 Everything said about gravity above applies to the speed of light -- equations, but no low-lewel model.

So when scientists observe faster-than-light neutrinos, they are flummoxed.  Spring-And-Loop Theory isn't.

Another profound conclusion of Spring-And-Loop Theory's model?  Realizing the photon is not a particle.
 


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has a simple neutrino model? 17 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
17 When it comes to neutrinos, tEmP theories are essentially bankrupt.

COASALT 9: Neutrino covers this subject in considerable detail and makes a number of predictions,
built on Spring-And-Loop Theory's basic foundation.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Resolves neutrino mass issue? 18 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
18 Aside from Spring-And-Loop Theory, no theory will ever come close to resolving the neutrino mass issue.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Explains FTL neutrinos? 19 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
19 Faster-than-light neutrinos break General Relativity, and send shockwaves through tEmP theories.

Handled, without having to change the model, in COASALT 9: Neutrino.
 


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Can explain dark energy? 20 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
20 Dark energy is a titanic embarrassment to tEmP theories. Their only hope is invention. Duct tape.

Spring-And-Loop Theory explained "dark energy" in the original paper.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Doesn't need dark matter? 21 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
21 "Dark matter" = a broken model of gravity.

Despite this, few theories are proposing new theories of gravity. Those that try, introduce staggering
levels of complexity -- an automatic fail.

Spring-And-Loop Theory deleted "dark matter" years ago.
 


SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has unresolved deal-breakers? 22 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
22 tEmP theories are minefields. Positively brimming with deal-breakers. Yet all are supported by
mainstream media. That know a profitable thing when they $ee it.

There is no profit in knowledge. This fact alone is the main reason why life today continues to decay.

Spring-And-Loop Theory cares about the physics. And is not in it for the money.

Can your theory say that?

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Thinks inflation theory is reasonable? 23 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
23 There should be a top ten list of things that are killing physics.

On such a list, the inflationary theory of cosmology would be duking it out for a top three spot.

A perfect example of "If your theory is broken, just create something out of thin air to paper it over".

Spring-And-Loop Theory has never had, and never will have, a need for such a ludicrous kludge.

In part because Spring-And-Loop Theory is philosophical, not religious.

Religion: shut up and accept what we say.
Philosophy: a study of life in its entirety.
SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Invents new particles to fix issues? 24 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
24 Did you know that the inflationary theory comes with a new particle: the inflaton?

Or that two new baryon particles, the 'heavyweight quark b'-' and the 'heavyweight quark b*-, were found
at CERN less than a year ago?

Mainstream media has expended most of their ammunition over the past few years pounding us, night
and day, with the "importance" of finding the Higgs particle.

Until they supposedly found it.

Next thing you know they are telling us "Ah, well, there must be an even more fundamental particle
that gives things mass."

Spring-And-Loop Theory avoids the never ending "we found a new particle!" carrot on a stick by just
working. Consistently. And at a lower, more fundamental, level.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires Super Partner particles? 25 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown PASS
25 Ah, SUSY, we hardly knew ya.

The sun appears to finally be setting on Supersymmetry. And not a decade too soon.

Supersymmetry is the desperate attempt by broken theories to try to be predictive.

tEmP theories insist life be as, well, symmetrical, as their theories try to be.
Because they have little else to offer.

Spring-And-Loop Theory is comfortable with edge effects, and doesn't try to insulate itself from them.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires particle families? 26 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS PASS
26 More Bondo from tEmP theories.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires superposition? 27 FAIL N.A. FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown PASS PASS
27 Mathematics, jealous of the publicity Physics has (unfairly) gained over the years,
has found ways to impose its whimsy on the world of the quantum.

Or has it?

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires wavefunction collapse? 28 FAIL N.A. FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown PASS PASS
28 The wonderful thing about tEmP theories is how they grow and spread.

One bit of nonsense necessitates a second bit. Then a third.

Spring-And-Loop Theory feels out of place amongst such childish artifice, having provided a more
fundamental explanation in COASALT 8: Quantum World.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Accepts "plus attracts minus" miracle? 29 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown Unknown PASS
29 The funny thing about miracles? Whenever you desperately need one, it magically appears!

Spring-And-Loop Theory: the "not desperate" theory.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Accepts "spooky action at a distance"? 30 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown Unknown PASS
30 Despite extending Newton's gravitational equation, Einstein was never comfortable with gravity's
"spooky action at a distance".

But everyone since Einstein seems to be.

Spring-And-Loop Theory figured out what must be going on to cause things to attract each other across
"empty space". And then had a delicious breakfast.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires stationary states of motion? 31 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown Unknown PASS
31 It is one thing to come up with mumble jumble like "stationary states of motion".

It is quite another thing to require them.

But then, self-criticism is not the strong suit of tEmP theories.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Tries to treat a muon like an electron? 32 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown Unknown PASS
32 This one stems from tEmP theories being too much in bed with the idea of particle families.

To tEmP theories, there have to be particle families.

And "like" particles must sleep together.

Even when they're not alike.   

Incest is wrong, kids. Very wrong.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Thinks negative experiments are proof? 33 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown Unknown PASS
33 Last time I checked, absence of evidence is still not evidence of absence.

Someone better tell tEmP theories...

By the way, this bit of particularly bad science has had a most unfortunate, and lasting, effect on physics.

I still want my ether back.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Requires dogmatic acceptance? 34 FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown FAIL FAIL PASS PASS
34 Ever heard the phrase "Shut up and calculate"?
It is one of the cornerstones of Quantum Mechanics, apparently.

Then there is the Big Bang and its inflationary prodigy. Believe it or not.

String Theory's "appeal" at this point is little more than unquestioning loyalty.

Culminating with the THC-required gospel according to M-theory...

Spring-And-Loop Theory thinks physics should be free from brainwashing.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Thinks particle smashing is useful? 35 FAIL Unknown FAIL Unknown FAIL FAIL PASS PASS
35 When you have a $10 billion dollar hammer, everything looks like a nail...that you can use to build
a six bedroom five bathroom retirement cottage with.

But when you have a better model, as Spring-And-Loop Theory does, you know that computer simulation
is the future of physics. And a thousand times cheaper for Joe and Jane taxpayer.

And that ain't no pork.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Has ludicrous fudge factors & infinities? 36 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL Unknown PASS
36 The most touted parts of the Standard Model -- the supposed unifications of QED, QCD & QFD -- are
built, quite literally, on top of an endless series of infinities.

Much like how cow factories used to feed the diseased carcasses back to other cows, such cannibalistic
approaches lead not to enlightenment, but rather to diseased thinking.

Spring-And-Loop Theory is vegetarian, by the way. Lacto ovo.
 



SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on the Standard Model? 37 N.A. N.A. N.A. FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
37 It is fascinating to realize how few of tEmP theories have enough guts to call the Standard Model what it is:

A sham, a scam...and a great way to build a long and illustrious career!

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on General Relativity? 38 N.A. N.A. N.A. FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
38 Ok, it might not have made it to the front page of "Joe's Science World", but Spring-And-Loop Theory
passed this milestone.

A  few  times.

But accomplishing this required adopting Einstein's favorite approach.

In-tu-i-tion, noun: it's what's for dinner.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on Quantum Mechanics? 39 N.A. N.A. N.A. FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
39 tEmP theories genuflect to Quantum Mechanics.

Spring-And-Loop Theory averts its gaze...

...then gives it the raspberry,

before a blow-by-blow pounding

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on String Theory? 40 FAIL FAIL FAIL N.A. FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
40 String improves on String Theory.

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on Quantum Field Theory? 41 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL N.A. FAIL FAIL PASS
41 Fundamentals   >>   probabilities & can't knows

SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on Gauge Theory? 42 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL N.A. FAIL PASS
42 I ask you, how hard is it to improve on this:
"In physics, a gauge theory is a type of field theory
in which the Lagrangian is invariant under a
continuous group of local transformations."
SM GR QM ST QFT GT LQG COASALT
Improves on Loop Quantum Gravity? 43 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL N.A. PASS
43 I hope Loop Quantum Gravity amounts to something.

Quick question, though.

Have you ever thought much about it?


 



Is a Theory of Everything? 44 FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL PASS
44 Today, the Existing mainstream Physics theories are farther away from being "theories of everything"
than they ever have been.

In fact, there is only one valid entrant in the "unification" sweepstakes:

Spring-And-Loop Theory


 


SUMMARY Standard General Quantum String Quantum Gauge Loop Quantum Spring-And-Loop
Model Relativity Mechanics Theory Field Theory Theory Gravity Theory
                                                FAIL: xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx
xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx
x x xx
                                                UNKNOWN: xxxxx xxxxxxxx x xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
xxx xx
                                                PASS: x x xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxx

 


Continue with... "Comparing Physics Theories"



 


 

COASALT

Introduction

The Speed Of Light   Black Holes   Einstein's Equation   The Ether   Gravity
222 Answers   The Atom   Quantum World   Neutrino   Black Holes Revisited
The Comedy Of Science   et=mc3   Comparing Physics Theories
Diffuse Interstellar Bands   Einstein's Ether Talk   No Strong Force
The Electron   Relativity   Unification   Assumptions   Modeling
 


 


Spring-And-Loop Theory by Floyd Maxwell is licensed
under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Other subjects   Site Map   Contact
 

Quotes provided by:

Click here (then click Join Group) to subscribe